Friday, May 21, 2010





Dentists, Dental Association Failed to Allege Fraud in RICO Claim Against Insurers

This posting was written by Mark Engstrom, Editor of CCH RICO Business Disputes Guide.

Three dentists and the American Dental Association (ADA) failed to assert a plausible class-action RICO claim against five insurance companies that allegedly engaged in a scheme to defraud dentists by reducing payments for dental services through improper bundling, automatic downcoding, and the manipulation of dental procedure codes, the U.S. Court of Appeals in Atlanta has held. The dismissal of the plaintiffs’ RICO claims was therefore affirmed.

Bundling and Downcoding Procedures

The plaintiffs complained that they performed multiple procedures worthy of larger benefit payments, but that the insurers had bundled and “downcoded” those procedures into fewer claims worthy of small payments.

The plaintiffs also alleged that the fraudulent scheme would work only if the insurers had agreed to employ the same devices and tactics.

According to the plaintiffs, the insurers sent out letters and e-mails stating that dental procedures submitted as multiple claims would be grouped together as a single procedure for the purpose of benefits payments.

The plaintiffs failed, however, to (1) identify any specific misrepresentations in the letters and e-mails; (2) connect the allegedly fraudulent communications to particular acts of downcoding or bundling; or (3) allege how the insurers had agreed to employ these procedures as part of a long-term criminal enterprise predicated on mail and wire fraud, the court observed.

Conspiracy

Because the allegations in the plaintiffs’ complaint did not support an inference of an agreement to the overall object of the conspiracy—or an agreement to commit at least two predicate acts—the complaint failed to assert a valid RICO conspiracy claim. In the court’s view, the allegations contained only conclusory statements and unwarranted deductions of fact.

Plaintiffs, for example, attempted to bolster their conspiracy claim by describing the defendants’ “collective” or parallel actions, from which they inferred the existence of an agreement. The court noted, however, that the U.S. Supreme Court has stated that “when allegations of parallel conduct are set out . . . they must be placed in a context that raises a suggestion of a preceding agreement, not merely parallel conduct that could just as well be independent action (Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 2007-1 Trade Cases ¶75,709).

Lawful, Independent Conduct

In this case, there existed—for each of the collective actions alleged—an “obvious alternative explanation” that suggested lawful, independent conduct, the appellate court determined. The allegation that the insurers had downcoded and bundled claims, for example, could be attributed to the use of computers, which could process claims efficiently. Downcoding and bundling may be proper in a competitive market, the court reasoned, in order to decrease physicians’ costs and increase corporate profits.

The argument that a conspiracy could be inferred from the insurers’ participation in trade associations and other professional groups was unavailing. According to the court, it was “well settled before Twombly” that participation in trade organizations “provides no indication of a conspiracy.”

The May 14 decision, American Dental Association v. Cigna Corp., appears at CCH RICO Business Disputes Guide ¶11,843.

Thursday, May 20, 2010





Marketing of “Original Formula” Classic Coke Was Not Unfair or Deceptive

This posting was written by William Zale, Editor of CCH Advertising Law Guide.

Coca-Cola’s marketing of “Classic,” “Original Formula” Coke with high fructose corn syrup (HFCS) substituted for sucrose was not an unfair practice under the Illinois Consumer Fraud Act, the federal district court in East St. Louis, Illinois has ruled.

Claims that the marketing was a deceptive practice failed for either lack of causation of injury or time limitations, the court held.

Three factors are to be considered in determining whether a trade practice is unfair:

(1) whether the practice offends public policy;

(2) whether it is immoral, unethical, oppressive, or unscrupulous; and

(3) whether it causes substantial injury to consumers.

No public policy of Illinois proscribed the used of HFCS. Because a purchaser was unaware of Coca-Cola’s use of “Original Formula” to market the product, he was not oppressed by the practice. Finally, there was no substantial injury because the purchaser or any other consumer could have drunk a different beverage, according to the court.

Causation

Because the purchaser never saw the words “Original Formula” on containers of Classic Coke, his deceptive practices claim necessarily foundered on the issue of causation, according to the court. An unjust enrichment claim based on the deceptive practices theory also failed.

Time Limitations

Another purchaser’s claims were time-barred because she reasonably knew or could have known in the 1990s of her alleged injury from Coca-Cola’s marketing but failed to bring suit until well into the next decade. The consumer fraud statute of limitations was three years, and the limitation for unjust enrichment was five years.

The April 27 opinion in Kremers v. Coca-Cola Co. is reported at CCH Advertising Law Guide ¶63,835 and CCH State Unfair Trade Practices Law ¶32,051.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010





FTC Approves Combination of Scientific Equipment Manufacturers

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Agilent Technologies Inc., a supplier of scientific measurement instruments, closed it acquisition of medical device and software maker Varian, Inc. on May 14, after the parties entered into a proposed FTC consent order.

Under the terms of the proposed consent order, the companies agreed to sell three product lines in order to resolve FTC antitrust concerns over their combination.

According to the FTC's complaint, with the divestitures, Agilent's acquisition of Varian would have violated U.S. antitrust laws by reducing competition for three types of scientific measurement instruments in which the companies competed with one another.

The companies competed in the markets for the production and sale of micro gas chromatography instruments (Micro GCs), triple quadrupole gas chromatography-mass spectrometry instruments (3Q GC-MS), and inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) instruments.

The FTC contended that in each market, without the proposed divestitures, the acquisition would have allowed Agilent to raise prices, decrease innovation, or reduce customer service. According to the complaint, Agilent and Varian were the only two competitors producing Micro GCs, and the acquisition would leave Agilent with a monopoly in that market.

Similarly, in the 3Q GC-MS and ICP-MS markets, there are currently only four competing firms. Eliminating the competition between Agilent and Varian would leave Agilent with a post-merger market share of nearly 50 percent in each market.

With the closing of the deal, which "brings together two Silicon Valley pioneers," Agilent was now positioned as a leading provider of analytical instrumentation to the applied and life sciences markets, the company said in a May 14 statement.

The complaint and proposed consent order, In the Matter of Agilent Technologies, Inc., FTC File No. 0910135, announced May 14, 2010, are available on the FTC website. Further details will appear in CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Monday, May 17, 2010





Inventory Requirement, Control of Supplies Might Be “Franchise Fee” Under Washington Law

This posting was written by John W. Arden.

A supplier’s requirement that distributors maintain a particular level of inventory and its control over the supplies sent to the distributors might constitute a “franchise fee” within the Washington Franchise Investment Protection Act, according to the U.S. Court of Appeals in San Francisco.

Summary dismissal of the distributors' franchise law claims (CCH Business Franchise Guide ¶13,338 and ¶13,437)—based on its failure to establish that it paid a “franchise fee”—was reversed, and the claim was remanded to the federal district court in Spokane, Washington.

Mandatory Purchases

Payments for “the mandatory purchase of goods or services” are considered franchise fees under the Washington Franchise Investment Protection Act’s definition of “franchise.” (Wash. Rev. Code §19.100.010 (12)), the appeals court held.

The complaining distributors claimed that their supplier (Pepperidge Farm) effectively required them to purchase goods by mandating inventory levels and controlling pallet shipments “and then requiring [them] to pay for some product that went stale prior to sale.”

While the district court ruled that the distributors were never required to purchase a set quantity of Pepperidge Farm products, the distributors “submitted evidence to support their claim to the contrary,” the appeals court said, finding a genuine dispute of material fact that precluded summary judgment.

Business Opportunity Law

The appellate court upheld the summary dismissal of other claims brought by the distributors—including claims brought under the Washington Business Opportunity Fraud Act and negligent misrepresentation. It was not apparent that a distributorship was a “business opportunity” under the statute, and the distributors offered no counter argument, the court held.

The negligent misrepresentation claim was rejected on the ground that the distribution agreement specifically required the distributor to remove stale Pepperidge Farm products from store shelves and provided that Pepperidge Farm had no obligation to accept stale goods.

Commercially Reasonable Sale

The district court’s finding that Pepperidge Farm’s sale of the distributorship to the complaining distributor was commercially reasonable under the Washington Uniform Commercial Code (CCH Business Franchise Guide ¶14,145) was upheld on appeal.

“Pepperidge Farm undertook efforts in excess of ordinary procedures for marketing a distributorship, easily satisfying the standard for a commercially reasonable sale,” the Ninth Circuit ruled.

The May 14 not-for-publication opinion is Atchley v. Pepperidge Farm Inc., No. 09-35275. Text of the decision will appear in the CCH Business Franchise Guide.

Friday, May 14, 2010





Advertisers Can Pursue Suit Against Facebook for “Invalid Click” Charges

This posting was written by William Zale, Editor of CCH Advertising Law Guide.

Advertisers that entered into “cost per click” arrangements for ads posted on Facebook stated claims that Facebook breached its agreement to charge only for “legitimate clicks” and violated the California Unfair Competition law, the federal district court in San Jose has ruled.

The advertisers’ class action complaint alleged that Facebook charged for “invalid clicks” and “fraudulent clicks” on ads posted on its social networking website.

Disclaimer—Click Fraud

The court agreed with Facebook’s argument that the advertisers failed to state a claim for breach of contract based on fraudulent clicks because the contract expressly waived liability for third-party click fraud.

The contract disclaimer provided that “Facebook shall have no responsibility or liability to me in connection with any third party click fraud or other improper action that may occur.” The term “click fraud” directly followed the disclaimer’s reference to “clicks or other actions affecting the cost of the advertising” that are generated by third parties for “fraudulent or improper purposes.”

Invalid Clicks

However, the advertisers stated a claim for breach of contract at least as to “invalid clicks” resulting from Facebook’s own conduct, the court held.

The advertisers alleged that “invalid clicks” can result from deficiencies in Facebook’s system as a result of “(a) technical problems; (b) system implementation errors; (c) various types of unintentional clicks; (d) incomplete clicks that fail to open the advertiser’s web page; and (e) improperly recorded or unreadable clicks originating in some cases from an invalid proxy server or unknown browser types.”

“Invalid clicks” arguably need not be fraudulent, improper, or the result of the actions of third parties. The language of the contract was reasonably susceptible to this interpretation, the court determined.

Unfair Competition Law

The advertisers had standing to assert California Unfair Competition Law claims, according to the court. The allegation of a systematic breach of contract was sufficient for a claim under the statute predicated on unlawful business practices.

Although the advertisers failed to allege the element of reliance required to pursue a claim based on fraud, they succeeded in stating a claim that they reasonably could not have avoided the injury because of the ambiguities in the disclaimer, the court concluded.

The opinion in Facebook PPC Advertising Litigation will be reported at CCH Advertising Law Guide ¶63,836

Thursday, May 13, 2010





Public Workshop Will Focus on Intersection of Patent, Competition Policy

This posting was written by John W. Arden.

The Federal Trade Commission, Department of Justice, and the Department of Commerce’s U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) will hold a joint public workshop on Wednesday, May 26, on the intersection of patent policy and competition policy and its implications for promoting innovation.

In recent years, federal agencies and the courts have recognized that patents and competition share the overall purpose of promoting innovation and enhancing consumer welfare, according to the Commission.

The competitive drive of a dynamic marketplace fosters the introduction of new and improved products and processes, and high-quality patents promote investment in innovation. Delay, uncertainty, or poor patent quality can stifle innovation—as can unclear or inappropriate antitrust standards, said the FTC announcement.

Program Schedule

Opening remarks for the morning session will be delivered by Assistant Attorney General for the Department of Justice Antitrust Division Christine Varney; Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director of the USPTO David J. Kappos; and U.S. Chief Technology Officer Aneesh Chopra. FTC Commissioner Edith Ramirez will open the afternoon session with introductory remarks.

The program will address (1) The Patent Backlog: The Competitive Challenges for Innovators; (2) Permanent Injunctions in the District Courts and the International Trade Commission; and (3) Standard Setting, Patent Rights, and Competition Policy.

A wrap-up discussion will be lead by Carl Shapiro, Deputy Assistant Attorney General for Economic Analysis at the Department of Justice Antitrust Division; Joseph Farrell, Director of the Bureau of Economics, Federal Trade Commission; and Stuart Graham, Chief Economist for the USPTO.

The all-day workshop will convene at 9 a.m. at the USPTO’s campus at 600 Dulany Street, Madison Building Auditorium, Alexandria, Virginia. Details appear here on the FTC website.

Wednesday, May 12, 2010





Trade Regulation Tidbits

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

News, updates, and observations:

 House Transportation Committee Chair James L. Oberstar (D, Minn.) announced his opposition to the proposed merger between United Airlines and Continental Airlines in a conference call with reporters on May 6. Rep. Oberstar sent a letter on May 5 to Christine A. Varney, Assistant Attorney General in charge of the Department of Justice Antitrust Division, urging the agency’s disapproval of the proposed merger. "If United and Continental merge, another domino in a chain of mergers will fall, and there will be strong pressure for further consolidation, " Oberstar’s letter reads. "As I predicted when I wrote your predecessor in 2008 on the Delta-Northwest merger, approval of that merger created conditions that have persuaded Delta’s competitors to pursue their own combinations. The United-Continental transaction is the latest, but it likely will not be the last." The text of the letter is available here on the website of the U.S. House of Representatives Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

 Former FTC Chairman Timothy J. Muris is the 2010 recipient of the Miles W. Kirkpatrick Award for Lifetime FTC Achievement. The award was announced on May 5. “Tim Muris provided inspired service to the Federal Trade Commission and to the American public,” FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz said, citing Muris’s contributions and the agency’s mission to protect consumers and encourage competition. “He understood the value of combining economic and legal analyses with common sense, and the measures he advanced to realize this vision, such as the National Do Not Call Registry, raised the FTC’s stature among public institutions throughout the world and among our nation’s consumers.” Muris served as FTC Chairman from 2001 through 2004. Earlier, he held other key positions at the Commission, including Director of the Bureau of Competition, Director of the Bureau of Consumer Protection, and Assistant Director of the Planning Office. Currently, Muris is of counsel at the law firm of O’Melveny & Myers and is Co-Chair of the firm's Antitrust/Competition Practice. Further details appear here on the FTC website.

 Four current and former British Airways executives have been acquitted of price fixing charges by a jury in London, the United Kingdom Office of Fair Trading (OFT) announced in a May 10 press release. The OFT said that it asked the jury to acquit the defendants in the U.K.'s first criminal competition law trial following "the discovery last week of a substantial volume of electronic material, which neither the OFT nor the defence had previously been able to review." The OFT said: "Given that the trial had already begun and the volume of material involved, the OFT accepts that to continue with the trial in light of this unforeseen development would be potentially unfair to the defendants." The OFT "acknowledge[d] responsibility for its part in this oversight, which occurred at a time when the UK criminal cartel regime was still relatively new and the OFT's approach to the handling of leniency applications in the context of parallel criminal and civil investigations was still evolving." The OFT also said that it would review the role played by Virgin Atlantic Airways and its advisers in light of the airline's obligations, as a leniency applicant, to cooperate with the OFT. The previously-undisclosed electronic material included e-mails sent or received by a former Virgin Atlantic employee. In an August 7, 2008 press release, the OFT announced that it had charged four individuals with cartel offenses, in connection with its criminal investigation into price-fixing of fuel surcharges for long-haul passenger flights. The individuals were alleged to have dishonestly agreed with others to make or implement arrangements that directly or indirectly fixed the price for the supply of passenger air transport services by British Airways and Virgin Atlantic Airways in the United Kingdom. The charges related to a period between July 2004 and April 2006, when the defendants were employed by British Airways.

Tuesday, May 11, 2010





False Tooth Makers’ Claims Against Monopolist Cleared for Trial, Leading to Settlement

This posting was written by Darius Sturmer, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Artificial tooth maker Dentsply International, Inc. could have engaged in unlawful monopolization through practices that included tooth swaps with dental product dealers and the offering of loyalty rebates to exclusive dealers, the federal district court in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, has ruled.

The two dental supply manufacturers asserting the claim, Univac Dental Company and Lactona Corporation, presented sufficient evidence of damages from the tooth swaps and dealer exclusivity policies—which included Dentsply’s maintenance and enforcement of a policy prohibiting the dealers from adding competitors’ artificial teeth to their product lines—to survive summary judgment, the court stated.

At the outset, the court noted that the complaining manufacturers were not entitled to a preclusive finding that Dentsply’s actions injured them based upon an appellate court’s determination—in a government enforcement action, U.S. v. Dentsply Int’l, Inc.—that the tooth maker’s actions harmed all of its competitors, including the corporate predecessor of both Univac and Lactona, Universal Dental Company (2005-1 Trade Cases ¶74,706).

Causation and Damages

Collateral estoppel did not operate to resolve the issues of causation and damages in the case because, in the prior action, the issues—as they related to Univac and Lactona—were not fully litigated. Moreover, the determination of any issues related to them was not essential to that prior judgment. Thus, they were required to prove damages in the present case.

The court rejected Dentsply’s argument that Univac and Lactona would not be able to show that Dentsply’s actions foreclosed a sufficiently significant portion of the market because they were still able to maintain access to dealers through a grandfather exception to the exclusivity policy.

No legal authority required an individual competitor to prove that its own access to the market had been foreclosed in order to make a showing that it was injured or that the challenged practices severely restricted the market’s ambit, the court explained.

Anticompetitive, Injurious Actions

The complaining manufacturers did not fail to meet their burden of showing that Dentsply took action that was both anticompetitive and injurious to them within the statute of limitations period. Although the evidence was not conclusive, it was sufficient to present the issue to a finder of fact, the court said.

A contention that it would be improper to consider evidence of actions directed not only toward Univac and Lactona specifically, but also that infringed competition in the relevant market generally, was without merit.

Evidentiary Matters

In the same opinion, the court also ruled on several evidentiary matters intended to clear the path to trial. It confirmed that a magistrate judge’s refusal to grant preclusive effect to several proposed factual findings was proper. In addition, the court declined to reject several of the magistrate’s recommended findings regarding the effects of Dentsply’s conduct on the basis that they were allegedly inapplicable or misleading. Any potential for one particular finding to mislead the jury could be alleviated by the defendant’s evidence and arguments, in the court’s view.

The fact that several other findings referred to competitors other than Univac and Lactona did not render those findings misleading, inaccurate, or immaterial. A reference to events occurring outside the limitations period applicable to the suit did not warrant another finding’s rejection.

Amount of Damages

In a separate ruling issued on April 27, the court found that expert testimony offered to establish the amount of damages suffered by the complaining manufacturers was sufficiently reliable and fit to the facts to be admitted into evidence. Objections by the defendant to the testimony were more directly related to its probative value than to its admissibility.

he testimony was based upon a proper foundation, the court said, and the expert’s calculation of an estimated amount of damages without regard to causation or any other elements of liability was “perfectly acceptable.”

Settlement

One day after the latter ruling on expert testimony, the parties reportedly reached an agreement to avoid going to trial. On April 29, the presiding judge in the matter, Christopher Conner of the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, signed a dismissal order allegedly acknowledging that the matter had been settled.

None of the involved companies has issued a statement divulging the terms of the settlement, but the dismissal order purportedly noted that either side could reinstate the action within 60 days if the settlement does not get consummated.

The March 31 and April 27 rulings in Univac Dental Co. v. Dentsply International, Inc., Civil Action No. 1:07-CV-0493, appears at 2010-1 Trade Cases ¶76,998 and ¶76,999.

Monday, May 10, 2010





Comment Period on Proposal to Revise Merger Guidelines Extended

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

The FTC has extended the period for submitting public comments on a proposed revision of the Horizontal Merger Guidelines. At the request of several organizations that plan to submit comments, the agency has agreed to accept comments through June 4, 2010.

The updated guidelines, which outline how the federal antitrust agencies evaluate the likely competitive impact of mergers and whether those mergers comply with U.S. antitrust law, are being revised jointly by the FTC and Department of Justice.

The proposed Guidelines were issued on April 20, 2010, and the original comment period was set to expire on May 20, 2010.

Text of the proposed revised guidelines appear at CCH Trade Regulation Reporter ¶50,252 and here on the FTC website.

Details on the issuance of the guidelines appear in an April 20, 2010 posting on Trade Regulation Talk.

Friday, May 07, 2010





FTC Alleges Merger-to-Monopoly in Market for Education Marketing Information

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Dun & Bradstreet Corporation’s 2009 acquisition of the assets of Quality Education Data (QED), a division of Scholastic, Inc., “is in practical effect a merger-to-monopoly” in the market for kindergarten through twelfth grade educational marketing data, the Federal Trade Commission alleged in an administrative complaint announced today. The agency is seeking divestitures of assets necessary to restore the competition that allegedly was lost as a result of the acquisition.

Prior to the transaction, Dun & Bradstreet's Market Data Retrieval and QED were the only two significant competitors in the K-12 data market, according to the agency. As a result of the acquisition, Market Data Retrieval, which describes itself as “the market’s first choice for marketing information and services for the K-12, higher education, library, early childhood, and related education markets,” allegedly holds over 90 percent of the K-12 data market.

Educational marketing data includes contact, demographic, and other information relating to teachers, administrators, schools, and individual school districts, that is sold or leased to customers, the FTC explained. The data sold by these companies is used to sell books, education materials, and other products to teachers and other educators nationwide.

Low-Dollar-Value Transaction

Dun & Bradstreet acquired the QED assets for approximately $29 million. Because the transaction fell below the threshold for premerger notification filings under the Hart-Scott-Rodino (H-S-R) Act, the federal antitrust agencies did not have had an opportunity to require the parties to wait to consummate the transaction while its potential competitive effects were considered pursuant to the H-S-R program. Nevertheless, the FTC ultimately discovered the transaction.

“Despite its relatively low dollar value, this transaction dramatically decreased competition in the marketplace,” said FTC Bureau of Competition Director Richard Feinstein. “When Dun & Bradstreet acquired QED, it bought its closest competitor and created a monopoly. That’s going to get the FTC’s attention every time.”

The Commission vote approving the administrative complaint was four-to-one, with Commissioner J. Thomas Rosch voting against. The complaint, In the Matter of The Dun & Bradstreet Corporation, FTC Docket No. 9342, will appear at CCH Trade Regulation Reporter ¶16,445.

Thursday, May 06, 2010





Draft of Proposed Federal Privacy Legislation Released

This posting was written by Thomas A. Long, Editor of CCH Privacy Law in Marketing.

A discussion draft of legislation to protect the privacy of information about individuals both on the Internet and offline was released by Representatives Rick Boucher (D, Virginia) and Cliff Stearns (R, Florida) on May 4.

Privacy Policy

The measure would require companies that collect personally identifiable information about individuals to conspicuously display a clear, understandable privacy policy that explains how such information is collected, used, and disclosed to third parties.

General Rule for Collecting Information

According to Boucher and Stearns, the proposed legislation would set forth a general rule that companies are permitted to collect information about individuals unless an individual affirmatively opted out of that collection. No consent would be required to collect and use operational or transactional data—such as session cookies—or to use data that was rendered anonymous.

Opt-In Consent Requirement

The legislation would require companies to obtain express opt-in consent before collecting sensitive information about an individual, including medical data, financial account information, Social Security numbers, sexual orientation, government-issued identifications information, and precise geographic location data.

Affirmative opt-in permission would have to be obtained before a company could share an individual’s personally identifiable information with unaffiliated third parties, other than for an operational or transactional purpose.

The draft bill would create an exception to this opt-in consent requirement by applying opt-out consent to the sharing of information with a third-party ad network, as long as there is a clear, easy-to-find link to a webpage for the ad network that allows a person to edit his or her profile and to opt out of having a profile.

FTC Implementation, Enforcement

The Federal Trade Commission would be directed to adopt rules to implement and enforce the measure. States could also enforce the FTC’s rules through state attorneys general or state consumer protection agencies. The legislation would not create a private right of action.

The law would preempt any state law that included requirements regarding the collection, use, or disclosure of information covered by the federal statute.

A news release and full text of the discussion draft appears on Representative Boucher’s website.

Wednesday, May 05, 2010





Antitrust Enforcers Reportedly Set to Probe Apple’s License Agreement

This posting was written by John W. Arden.

According to published reports, the Federal Trade Commission and Department of Justice are negotiating to determine which agency will pursue an antitrust inquiry of Apple Computer Inc.’s new license agreement, which requires software developers to use Apple programming tools to create applications for the iPhone and iPad.

Apple’s license agreement would prevent developers from employing other tools—such as Adobe Systems Inc.’s Flash format—used to create web videos, games, and other interactive features.

Antitrust enforcers will address the issue of whether this policy injures competition by forcing developers to choose between designing applications that can run only on the iPhone and iPad and creating applications that are “platform neutral” and can run on operating systems produced by Google, Microsoft, and others.

A story ("An antitrust app") in Monday’s New York Post said that federal antitrust enforcers are “days away from making a decision about which agency will launch the inquiry,” which could lead to a full fledged investigation.

None of the players in the scenario—the FTC, the Department of Justice, or Apple Computer Inc.—has publicly commented on the news reports. However, Apple CEO Steve Jobs posted a piece (“Thoughts on Flash”) on the company website, explaining “why we do not allow Flash on iPhones, iPods and iPads.”

Rather than being “primarily business driven,” the decision was “based on technology issues,” according to Jobs. Contrary to Adobe’s claims, Flash is actually “a closed system,” while Apple has adopted “open standards” like HTML5, CSS and JavaScript, Jobs wrote.

While Adobe contends that Apple mobile devices cannot access “the full web” because 75% of the video on the web is in Flash, Jobs maintained that “almost all this video is also available in a more modern format, H.264, and viewable on iPhones, iPods and iPads.”

Jobs further cited reliability, security, and performance issues, arguing that Flash has a poor security record, causes Macs to crash, and does not perform well on mobile devices. In addition, Jobs criticized Flash for using too much battery power, for not being designed for “touch” screens, and for having “major technical drawbacks.”

The Wall Street Journal (“Apple Attracts Scrutiny From Regulators”) pointed out that the “growing interest in Apple’s activities by antitrust authorities shows the extent to which the Cupertino, Calif., company has become a powerful player in mobile devices like smartphones, which many people see as the next dominant computing platform after personal computers.”

The article compares Apple’s conduct with the tactics by Microsoft Corp. that drew attention from antitrust enforcers in the 1990s.

“Apple is playing right out of Microsoft’s playbook—and it’s one they complained about a lot,” said David Balto, a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress and former attorney for the FTC and Department of Justice.

Tuesday, May 04, 2010





Trade Regulation Tidbits

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

News, updates, and observations:

 Senator Herb Kohl (D, Wis.), chairman of the Senate Antitrust Subcommittee, said his subcommittee was likely to hold a hearing to examine whether the merger of Continental and United Airlines will lead to higher prices or lower quality of service. Continental and United announced a difinititve merger agreement on May 3. The carriers said that the combination would “bring together the two most complementary networks of any U.S. carriers, with minimal domestic and no international route overlaps.” In a May 3 statement, Senator Kohl commented that the merger “would create the nation’s largest airline and will no doubt affect the travel choices for millions of consumers across the nation.” While voicing concern that the major airlines face competitive pressures and high costs, Kohl spoke of a “need to insure that airline consolidation does not diminish the competitive choices for air travelers.”

 Legislation to extend permanently the Antitrust Criminal Penalties Enforcement and Reform Act (ACPERA) of 2004 was introduced in the Senate on April 27. Senator Herb Kohl (D, Wis.), sponsor of the measure, said “permanent extension of ACPERA would encourage participation in the Antitrust Division’s leniency program.” ACPERA limits the civil liability of leniency participants to the actual damages caused by that company, rather than treble damages usually available in civil antitrust lawsuits. The law was amended in 2009 to extend the de-trebling provision for one year. Without amendment, it would expire in June. The measure (S. 3259), which was co-sponsored by Senator Orrin Hatch (R, Utah), also calls for the Comptroller General to submit a report to the Committees on the Judiciary of the House of Representatives and the Senate on the effectiveness of the Antitrust Criminal Penalties Enforcement and Reform Act of 2004.

 The FTC told congressional lawmakers that the rapid-fire pace of technological change, including an explosion in children’s use of mobile devices and interactive gaming, has led the agency to accelerate its review of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Rule (COPPA Rule) to make sure that it is still adequately protecting children’s privacy. Although the FTC reviews most of its rules every 10 years, the COPPA Rule is being reviewed only five years after its last review, in 2005. The comments were made in agency testimony, prepared for delivery by Jessica Rich, Deputy Director of the FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection, before the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee's Subcommittee on Consumer Protection, Product Safety, and Insurance on April 29. The FTC’s COPPA Rule, which took effect in 2000, requires operators of Web sites and online services that target children under age 13 to obtain verifiable parental consent before they collect, use, or disclose personal information from children. The operators must give parents the opportunity to review and delete personal information their children have provided.

Monday, May 03, 2010





States Keep Passing Franchise and Distribution Laws, but Focus on Special Industries

This posting was written by John W. Arden.

State legislatures continue to pass a significant number of statutes regulating franchise and distribution arrangements, but have turned their focus to enacting special industry laws rather than generally-applicable laws, according to Richard H. Casper, speaking April 29 at Foley & Lardner’s 19th annual Law of Product Distribution and Franchise Seminar in Milwaukee.

In 2009, the states passed 65 laws enacting or amending distribution statutes. There are currently more than 100 bills affecting the field pending in the legislatures.

Themes of Legislation

Casper identified several themes of legislation, including the enactment of laws (1) increasing restrictions on suppliers, (2) tweaking protections afforded motor vehicle dealerships, (3) focusing on specific industries, and (4) expanding anti-termination measures provided to dealers of motor vehicles and farm and construction equipment to watercraft, recreational vehicle, and lawn and garden equipment dealers.

In contrast, the states generally have shied away from further legislation covering independent sales representatives and farm equipment dealerships. The redraft of Uniform Commercial Code Article 2—proposed by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform States Laws in 2003—has not been adopted in any state, Casper said.

Three states and the federal government have adopted statutes requiring restaurant chains to disclose the nutritional content of menu items. This year, New Jersey has amended its Franchise Practices Act to govern franchisees maintaining virtually any kind of location within the state. Previously, the law applied to franchisees that maintained a retail location within New Jersey.

Maryland has expanded the scope of its Equipment Dealer Contract Act to cover heating, ventilation, and air conditioning dealers in the business of selling “on commission or at retail.”

Product Distribution Law Guide

The attorneys in the Foley & Lardner Distribution & Franchise Practice group have authored a one-volume treatise based on the firm’s annual Product Distribution and Franchise seminar. CCH Product Distribution Law Guide, Second Edition discusses distribution issues from both the legal and business perspective, providing practice tips, checklists, and a solutions-oriented approach. Further details about the Guide appear here on the CCH/Wolters Kluwer online store.

Friday, April 30, 2010





Focus on Franchising

This posting was written by Pete Reap, Editor of CCH Business Franchise Guide, and John W. Arden.

News and notes on franchising and distribution topics:

□ A provision of the recently-enacted health care reform legislation, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, requires restaurants that are part of a chain with 20 or more locations doing business under the same name to disclose nutritional information. The new law requires restaurants to display the number of calories contained in standard menu items (1) on the menu listing the item for sale, (2) in a written form available on the premises upon consumer request, and (3) on menu boards. Establishments will be required to display a succinct statement concerning suggested daily caloric intake, as specified by the Secretary of Health and Human Services by regulation, to enable the public to understand the significance of the provided nutrition information. Compliance with the law’s restaurant labeling provisions, which are reported at CCH Business Franchise Guide ¶14,357, will be required upon completion of implementing regulations by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The FDA is required to publish proposed regulations within one year of the law’s enactment.

□ On April 20, the European Commission (EC) approved a revised Block Exemption Regulation and Guidelines on supply and distribution agreements, including franchise and other types of vertical agreements. Block exemptions create safe harbors for categories of agreements, relieving the contracting parties from having to individually analyze the legality of those agreements under the general EC rules regarding vertical agreements. As revised, manufacturers remained free to decide how to distribute their products. But in order to benefit from the block exemption, they can not have a market share in excess of 30% and their distribution or supply agreements must not contain any hardcore restrictions of competition, such as fixing the resale price or re-creating barriers to the European Union's single market. The new rules, which come into force in June, also specifically addresses the question of online sales. Once a distributor is authrorized, it must be fee to sell on a website as well as in their traditional shops and physical points of sales. Further details about the new block exemption can be found here on the Europa website of the European Commission. Text of the block exemption appears here.

□ South Africa has adopted a new franchise law as part of its Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008, according to Field Fisher Waterhouse LLP. Key features of the initial provisions of the Act, which became effective on April 24, are (1) a mandatory 10-day “cooling off” period after the signing of a franchise agreement—during which time a franchisee may withdraw without incurring any liability and (2) a requirement that all franchise agreements be in writing and signed by franchisees. The definition of “franchise agreement” is broad and includes master franchise agreements and other arrangements (such as reseller agreements) that normally are not considered franchises. The main sections of the Act—which reportedly will extend fundamental consumer rights to franchisees—is expected to become effective on October 24, 2010. An article on the new law appears here on the Field Fisher Waterhouse website.

Thursday, April 29, 2010





Reverse Payment Patent Settlement Could Get Second Look from Full Second Circuit

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Federal Trade Commission Chairman Jon Leibowitz cited a decision handed down today by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals in New York City as “further evidence that courts are rethinking their approach to pay-for-delay settlements.”

Although the Second Circuit rejected an antitrust challenge to a settlement in a patent infringement lawsuit, it invited the plaintiffs to petition for rehearing en banc.

The court concluded that it was bound by an earlier Second Circuit circuit decision--Joblove v. Barr Labs., Inc. (In re Tamoxifen Citrate Antitrust Litig.), 2006-2 Trade Cases ¶75,382. In Tamoxifen, a divided court held that a reverse payment settlement of a patent lawsuit involving a drug used to treat breast cancer did not violate the antitrust laws.

In this latest decision, the court said: "we believe there are compelling reasons to revisit Tamoxifen with the benefit of the full Court’s consideration of the difficult questions at issue and the important interests at stake." The court referred to: "the 'exceptional importance' of the antitrust implications of reverse exclusionary payment settlements of patent infringement suits."

At issue in the current dispute are patent settlement agreements between Bayer AG/Bayer Corporation--owner of the patent for the active ingredient in the antibiotic ciprofloxacin hydrochloride (Cipro)--and potential generic manufacturers of Cipro. Direct purchasers of Cipro alleged that the settlements constituted market-sharing agreements in violation of the antitrust laws. They contended that Bayer paid generic drug companies to delay entry into the prescription drug market, thereby blocking the entry of low-cost generic versions of Cipro.

The court stated the question as: "whether patent settlements in which the generic firm agrees to delay entry into the market in exchange for payment fall within the scope of the patent holder’s property rights, or whether such settlements are properly characterized as illegal market-sharing agreements." The court noted that authorities are divided on the question.

Divided Authorities

Courts generally have held that the right to enter into reverse exclusionary payment agreements fall within the terms of the exclusionary grant conferred by the branded manufacturer’s patent, the court explained. On the other hand, the FTC and the current Department of Justice Antitrust Division contend that reverse exclusionary payment settlements violate antitrust law.

Tamoxifen Standard

Under Tamoxifen, a settlement agreement did not exceed the scope of the patent where (1) there was no restriction on marketing noninfringing products; (2) a generic version of the branded drug would necessarily infringe the branded firm’s patent; and (3) the agreement did not bar other generic manufacturers from challenging the patent. The complaining direct purchasers of Cipro did not argue that the patent infringement lawsuit was a sham or that the Cipro patent was procured by fraud, and they could not demonstrate that the settlement agreement exceeded the scope of the Cipro patent, the court explained.

FTC Chairman’s Statement

In a statement issued following the Second Circuit’s decision, FTC Chairman Leibowitz expressed hope that “the courts will put an end to these deals.” He stressed that, “[i]n the meantime, the FTC will continue to explain, in court and in the halls of Congress, why these sweetheart deals for drug companies are such a bad deal for American consumers and taxpayers.”

The April 29, 2010, decision, In re: Ciprofloxacin Hydrochloride Antitrust Litigation, Docket Nos. 05-2851-cv(L), 05-2852-cv(CON), appears at 2010-1 Trade Cases ¶76,989.

Wednesday, April 28, 2010





Agency Heads Discuss Revisions to Merger Guidelines at ABA Antitrust Meeting

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Antitrust practitioners reviewing proposed revisions to the federal antitrust agencies’ Horizontal Merger Guidelines should have a better understanding of current agency practice, according to federal antitrust enforcers speaking April 23 at an enforcement roundtable during the American Bar Association’s Section of Antitrust Law Spring Meeting in Washington, D.C.

The proposed revisions to the guidelines, which outline how the federal antitrust agencies evaluate the likely competitive effects of mergers in order to determine compliance with U.S. antitrust law, were released on April 20 in anticipation of the meeting. The proposed revised guidelines appear at CCH Trade Regulation Reporter ¶ 50,252.

Reflection of Agency Practice

Christine Varney, Assistant Attorney General in charge of the Department of Justice Antitrust Division, told meeting attendees at the enforcement roundtable that, while the proposed revised guidelines are not all that different in substance from the current 1992 guidelines, the 1992 guidelines do not reflect the actual practice at the agencies. This latest update is an effort to be transparent, according to Varney.

The antitrust chief reminded attendees that each transaction is viewed on the facts of that transaction. She noted the importance of direct evidence of a potential merger’s competitive effects in evaluating a merger. The role of direct evidence in merger analysis is reflected in the proposed updated guidelines, Varney said.

FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz also described the proposed revisions to the guidelines as an effort to explain to practitioners and judges what the agencies are doing when evaluating the competitive effects of mergers.

Leibowitz discussed the role of direct evidence of competitive effects in actions challenging Evanston Northwestern Healthcare Corporation’s 2000 acquisition of Highland Park Hospital and Western Refining, Inc.’s proposed acquisition of rival energy company Giant Industries, Inc., in 2007. He suggested that the judge in the latter case took a mechanistic view of the Horizontal Merger Guidelines in rejecting the FTC’s request for a preliminary injunction blocking Western Refining’s acquisition of Giant Industries.

Market Concentration

The proposed updates also raise the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) measures for market concentration in order to be more consistent with current agency practice, Leibowitz explained. As a result, mergers that would have appeared to be highly concentrated under the 1992 guidelines, based on HHI measures, would be considered only moderately concentrated under the proposed revised updates.

According to the guidelines, mergers that cause a significant increase in concentration and result in highly concentrated markets are presumed to be anticompetitive.

Merger Enforcement

Both agency heads took the opportunity to tout recent merger enforcement activity. Chairman Leibowitz said that the FTC was on “a little bit of a winning streak” in the merger enforcement area. He pointed to the decision of CCC Information Services Inc. to abandon its merger with Mitchell International Inc., in light of the agency’s challenge to the transaction.

The federal district court in Washington, D.C. had granted the FTC’s request for a preliminary injunction (PI) to block the transaction pending administrative litigation. The 2009 decision was the agency’s first PI win since 2003, according to the Commissioner.

Assistant Attorney General Varney discussed the Antitrust Division’s recent settlement with Ticketmaster Entertainment, Inc. In order to proceed with its proposed acquisition of concert promoter Live Nation, Inc., ticket seller Ticketmaster was required to license ticket software and divest a subsidiary ticketing business. In addition, behavioral remedies were imposed on Ticketmaster.

Varney told attendees that the agency’s preference was for structural relief, but that sometimes there is a need for both structural and behavioral remedies.

Canada Competition Bureau Merger Procedures

Canada Competition Commissioner Melanie Aitken, who was also on the roundtable panel, discussed recent changes to the merger review process north of the border. Aitken said that the changes “make for a far more effective merger review process.”

While she described the process as “Made in Canada,” Aitken noted that the reforms, which have to do with process and not substance, bring the merger review process more in line with U.S. practice. For instance, the two-stage review process replicates the second request process utilized by the federal antitrust agencies in the United States. Aitken said that the changes make coordination with her counterparts in the United States easier.

Tuesday, April 27, 2010





High Court Rules Class Arbitration in Price Fixing Case Was Improper

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

International shipping companies should not be forced to defend in class arbitration customers' price fixing claims where their arbitration clause was “silent” on the class arbitration issue, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled today in a five-to-three decision.

Finding that the arbitration panel erred in imposing class arbitration, the Court said: “instead of identifying and applying a rule of decision derived from the [Federal Arbitration Act] or either maritime or New York law, the arbitration panel imposed its own policy choice and thus exceeded its powers.”

Class Arbitration

A putative class action was brought against the shipping companies after a Department of Justice criminal investigation revealed an illegal price fixing conspiracy in 2003. After it was determined that the parties were required to arbitrate their antitrust dispute, the customers sought class arbitration of their claims. The arbitration panel granted the request but stayed the proceeding to allow the parties to seek judicial review.

The federal district court in New York City vacated the arbitration panel's clause-construction award (2006-2 Trade Cases ¶75,353); however, the federal appellate court subsequently reversed the district court and upheld the award. The federal appellate court held that class arbitration was permissible, even though the arbitration clauses in the underlying maritime agreements did not specifically provide for it (2008-2 Trade Cases ¶76,355).

“[P]arties may specify with whom they choose to arbitrate their disputes,” explained Justice Samuel Anthony Alito, writing for the majority, explained, in reversing the appellate court. The High Court cautioned courts and arbitrators “to give effect to the intent of the parties.”

Agreement Required

It followed that a party may not be compelled under the FAA to submit to class arbitration unless there was a contractual basis for concluding that the party had agreed to do so. In this matter, the parties had stipulated that there was “no agreement” on that issue, the Court noted.

Moreover, an agreement to authorize class arbitration could not be inferred based on the parties' “agreement to arbitrate" because class-action arbitration changed the nature of arbitration, according to the Court.

Dissent

The dissenting opinion, authored by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, argued that the majority was improperly addressing an issue not ripe for judicial review. The dissent contended that,
even if the matter was ripe for judicial review, the Court should have rejected it on the merits. The Court should have affirmed the Second Circuit judgment confirming the arbitrators’ clause-construction decision.

Text of the April 27 decision in Stolt-Nielsen S.A. v. Animalfeeds International Corp., 2010-1 Trade Cases ¶76,982, is posted here on the U.S. Supreme Court website.

Monday, April 26, 2010





Hotel Franchisor Not Liable for Patrons’ Contracting of Disease at Franchise

This posting was written by Pete Reap, Editor of CCH Business Franchise Guide.

A hotel franchisor that never voluntarily took on the task of maintaining the pool and spa at a franchised hotel was not directly or vicariously liable for hotel patrons’ alleged contracting of Legionnaires Disease, a federal district court in Springfield, Illinois, has decided.

Accordingly, the franchisor was entitled to summary judgment on the patrons’ claims based on an alleged duty of the franchisor to maintain the pool and spa (negligence, wrongful death, and two statutory claims) and on the claims based on the theory of apparent agency.

Negligence

It was clear that the franchise agreement did not create a duty on the part of the franchisor toward the patrons of the hotel, the court held. The franchisee owned the hotel, and the franchisor neither owned nor operated the hotel. The agreement specifically provided that the franchisee was an independent contractor. However, the face of the agreement was not controlling on the issue of duty, the court observed.

A franchisor must make sure that the franchisee maintained the required level of quality associated with the franchised brand in order to protect its trademarks. This monitoring could include setting standards for the operation of the franchise, retaining the right to inspect the franchise operation periodically, and retaining the right to withdraw the franchise or to close an aspect of the franchise operation for failure to comply with the franchisor’s standards.

A franchisor would not be responsible for the operation of a franchised hotel unless it asserted more direct control than these limited rights associated with maintaining the quality of its brand, according to the court.

The complaining patrons presented no evidence that the franchisor went beyond the limited steps necessary to maintain the level of quality associated its brand, the court determined. The franchisor made visual inspections of the pool and spa area twice a year at most and retained the right to close the pool and spa if the water was cloudy.

The franchisor also required, in its Rules and Regulations, that the hotel comply with the law. However, the franchisee had to meet these requirements anyway. The franchisor did not exercise sufficient control over the hotel to be considered an operator of the hotel.

Apparent Agency

To support an apparent agency theory of liability, the patrons presented evidence that one of the affected individuals believed that the franchisor operated the hotel. She testified that she believed this based on the franchisor’s commercial she saw on television.

The patrons also presented evidence that the franchisor operated a reservation system that used an "800" telephone number and an Internet website. Moreover, the franchisor operated a frequent traveler program in which customers could accumulate points that would entitle them to a free night’s stay at a participating franchise. However, none of that evidence
demonstrated that the franchisor held out the franchisee as its agent, the court ruled.

The use of the brand name showed a franchise relationship, but the existence of a franchise did not create an agency. In fact, the only evidence of representations regarding the relationship between the franchisor and the franchisee were the parties’ repeated disclaimers of any agency: the plaque in the lobby of the hotel that declared that the hotel was independently owned and operated, and a disclaimer on the franchisor’s website and in its directory, according to the court.

The decision is Braucher v. Swagat Group, LLC, CCH Business Franchise Guide ¶14,355

Friday, April 23, 2010





Denny’s Failure to Disclose Sodium Content of Meals Not a Deceptive Act

This posting was written by Jody Coultas, Editor of CCH State Unfair Trade Practices Law.

A restaurant patron could not state an Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act (CFA) against Denny’s Corporation for failing to disclose the sodium content of its meals, according to the federal district court in Chicago.

The patron began eating meals at Denny’s in 2004. He alleged that 75 percent of the meals at Denny’s contained an amount of sodium that far exceeds the daily recommended amount outlined by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). While the CDC recommends limiting sodium intake to 1,500 milligrams a day, one particular meal offered by Denny’s contained 5,600 milligrams.

Concealment of Sodium Content

Based on the health concerns associated with excessive sodium intake, the patron alleged that Denny’s knowingly concealed the amount of sodium used in its meals and that he and other customers would not have eaten at Denny’s had that information been made available.

Absence of Deceptive Communication

Because there was no deceptive communication presented as evidence, the CFA claim was dismissed by the court. To state a CFA claim, the patron needed to show a deceptive act or practice by Denny’s, intent on the part of Denny’s to deceive customers, and actual damages as a result of the deception.

The patron also needed to present a communication from Denny’s that contained a deceptive misrepresentation or omission. Consumers cannot maintain CFA claims without evidence of a communication even when the claim is based on an omission of material facts, according to the court:

"The Illinois Supreme Court has recently made it clear that a consumer cannot maintain an ICFA claim absent some communication from the defendant, either a communication containing a deceptive misrepresentation or one with a deceptive omission. De Bouse, 235 Ill. 2d at 555, 922 N.E.2d at 316."

The decision is Ciszewski v. Denny’s Corp., CCH State Unfair Trade Practices Law ¶32,026.

Thursday, April 22, 2010





Former Players Can Pursue Publicity Rights Claims Against NFL

This posting was written by William Zale, Editor of CCH Advertising Law Guide.

Former professional football players’ right of publicity claims against the National Football League could not be dismissed on the theory that NFL promotional videos did not constitute commercial speech and were entitled to First Amendment protection as expressive works, the federal district court in St. Paul has ruled.

The NFL allegedly violated the right of publicity statutes and common law of the 50 states by using the players’ names and images in promotional videos such as the “History” series, which included videos called the “Fabulous Fifties” and “Sensational 60s.”

Commercial Speech v. Expressive Works

While the films were not pure infomercials, their overwhelmingly positive tone belied the NFL’s contention that they were documentaries and supported the player’s contention that they were advertisements, according to the court.

Giving the players the benefit of all reasonable inferences at the stage of a motion to dismiss, they made out a plausible claim that the films referenced a specific product, NFL football, and that the constitutional protection to be afforded the films did not outweigh the players’ interests in their own identities.

Copyright Preemption

The Copyright Act did not preempt the right of publicity claims. The subject of a right of publicity—the name and likeness of a celebrity or other individual—was not a “work” within the subject matter of copyright law, the court reasoned.

Lanham Act False Endorsement

On Lanham Act false endorsement claims, a determination could not be made on the pleadings alone that the NFL’s use in promotional videos of former professional football players’ names and images was not “explicitly misleading” or likely to cause confusion, the court held.

The opinion in Dryer v. National Football League will be reported at CCH Advertising Law Guide ¶63,807.

Wednesday, April 21, 2010





Final Claims Dismissed in Novell’s Antitrust Suit Against Microsoft

This posting was written by Cheryl Beise, Editor of CCH Guide to Computer Law.

Software developer Novell, Inc. could not pursue two claims remaining in an antitrust action against Microsoft because Novell transferred the claims to a third party in an asset purchase agreement, the federal district court in Baltimore has ruled.

Novell alleged that Microsoft’s anticompetitive conduct in 1994-1996 damaged Novell’s ability to market its office productivity applications, including WordPerfect and Quattro Pro. In 2007, the district court dismissed as time-barred Novell’s claims alleging anticompetitive conduct in the office productivity applications market (2007-2 Trade Cases ¶75,901, CCH Computer Cases ¶49,423).

Novell’s remaining monopolization and restraint of trade claims, alleging harm in the operating systems market, were allowed to proceed because they were tolled during the pendency of the government’s action against Microsoft.

Assignment of Claims

In an Asset Purchase Agreement dated July 23, 1996, Novell assigned to Caldera, Inc., claims “held by Novell at the Closing Date and associated directly or indirectly with any of the DOS Products.”

Novell contended that the agreement meant to assign only claims for harm inflicted on the DOS products themselves, not on the operating system market, which comprised the actual market in which the DOS Products competed. However, the plain language of the assignment clause did not limit its application to claims inflicting “harm” on the DOS products; rather, it assigned claims “associated” with the DOS products, according to the court.

The APA assignment language encompassed the present claims because they were “associated directly or indirectly with the DOS Products.”

Merits

Despite finding that Novell lacked standing to pursue the claims at issue, the court nevertheless addressed the merits of each claim. If Novell had not transferred the claims to Caldera, Novell’s restraint of trade claim would have been decided in favor of Microsoft, but its monopolization claim would have proceeded to trial.

Novell alleged that Microsoft violated Sec. 2 of the Sherman Act by exclusive dealing—entering into “agreements with OEMs and others not to license or distribute Novell's office productivity applications.” To be considered “exclusive,” an agreement must expressly preclude a party from doing business with the defendant's competitors or engage in other conduct that has the practical effect of exclusivity.

Microsoft's agreements with computer manufacturers (OEMs) did not foreclose a substantial share of the software applications market, and its agreements with distributors were not exclusive or otherwise anticompetitive—they simply provided modest rebates for increased sales and “blended share” of Microsoft products.

With regard to its Sherman Act Sec. 1 claim, Novell’s evidence raised sufficient factual issues to preclude summary judgment. Although a monopolist generally has a right to refuse to cooperate with a competitor, Novell’s evidence suggested more, including that Microsoft acted out of predatory motives and affirmatively misled Novell about Windows 95 functionality and licensing.

The opinion, In re Microsoft Corp. Antitrust Litigation, is reported at CCH Guide to Computer Law ¶49,927. It will appear in CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010





FTC Proposes Updates to Horizontal Merger Guidelines

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Following a series of joint public workshops held by the FTC and Department of Justice over the past six months, the FTC is seeking public comment on a proposed revision of the Horizontal Merger Guidelines.

The updated guidelines—which outline how the federal antitrust agencies evaluate the likely competitive impact of mergers and whether those mergers comply with U.S. antitrust law—are being revised jointly by the federal antitrust agencies.

The guidelines were issued by the two agencies in 1992 and were last revised in 1997 (CCH Trade Regulation Reporter ¶13,104). The revisions are designed to more accurately reflect the way the agencies currently conduct merger reviews, according to the FTC’s April 20 announcement.

For instance, the proposed guidelines state that “merger analysis does not consist of uniform application of a single methodology.” Rather, it is a fact-specific process through which the agencies use a variety of tools to analyze the evidence to evaluate competitive concerns. In addition, the proposed guidelines explain that “market definition is not an end in itself: it is one of the tools the Agencies use to assess whether a merger is likely to lessen competition.”

Many parts of the proposed guidelines reflect refinements and changes previously identified in the “Commentary on the Horizontal Merger Guidelines, which the agencies jointly issued in 2006 (CCH Trade Regulation Reporter ¶50,208).

According to the FTC, the proposed revision includes an updated section on coordinated effects, an updated explanation of the hypothetical monopolist test, and a simplified discussion of how the agencies evaluate market entry. The proposed guidelines also include new sections on powerful buyers, mergers between competing buyers, and partial acquisitions.

Public comments are being accepted until May 20, 2010. Details appear here at the FTC web site.

Monday, April 19, 2010





Steak House Chain May Have Engaged in Racketeering Scheme to Violate Immigration Laws

This posting was written by Mark Engstrom, Editor of CCH RICO Business Disputes Guide.

Former employees of a Ruth’s Chris Steak House franchise in Birmingham, Alabama, sufficiently alleged that the franchisor, the franchisee, and the owner of the franchise had engaged in a racketeering scheme to violate federal immigration laws, the U.S. Court of Appeals in Atlanta, Georgia, has ruled.

According to the plaintiffs, the restaurant knowingly hired illegal aliens, allowed them to work under assumed names, and gave them Social Security numbers that belonged to former employees.

Alleged Immigration Violations

The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants had violated Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) provisions that made it a federal crime to: (1) knowingly hire ten or more illegal aliens during a twelve-month period; (2) conspire to commit—or to aid and abet—the unlawful importation, transportation, or harboring of illegal aliens, or the inducing of illegal aliens to enter or reside in the U.S.; (3) encourage or induce an alien to enter or reside in the U.S., with knowledge or in reckless regard of the fact that doing so would be illegal; and (4) knowingly or recklessly conceal, harbor, or shield an illegal alien.

Allegations that the defendants violated the first INA provision were insufficiently pled, the court determined, because the plaintiffs failed to allege that the defendants knew they were hiring employees that were brought into the U.S. illegally. Violations of the second INA provision were insufficiently pled because the relevant allegations were conclusory.

Successful Pleadings

Regarding the third INA provision, the court ruled that district court had improperly held that knowingly hiring illegal aliens—and then supplying them with fraudulent Social Security numbers that facilitated their employment—did not encourage or induce illegal aliens to enter or reside in the U.S.

Under RICO, the terms “encouraging” and “inducing” were broadly interpreted to include the act of “helping” illegals to enter or reside in the U.S. Although the district court had concluded that the “mere employment” of illegal aliens was not enough to encourage or induce them to enter the country or reside here, the plaintiffs had alleged more than mere employment. They alleged that the defendants had facilitated the employment of illegal aliens by giving them Social Security numbers that belonged to former employees.

This was sufficient to plead a RICO predicate act based on the INA provision that prohibited encouraging or inducing.

Finally, knowingly providing an illegal alien with employment, an assumed identity, an assumed Social Security number, and cash-based pay—all for the purpose of concealing, harboring, and shielding them from detection—was sufficient to establish a RICO predicate act based on a violation of the fourth INA provision.

The text of the April 9, 2010 decision in Edwards v. Prime Inc. will appear at CCH RICO Business Disputes Guide ¶11,835.

Thursday, April 15, 2010





Senate Judiciary Committee’s DOJ Oversight Hearing Touches on Antitrust Issues

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

The “Antitrust Division’s revitalized enforcement” was among the “many good things” accomplished by the Justice Department over the last year, Senator Herb Kohl (D-Wis.) said, commencing a Department of Justice oversight hearing held yesterday by the Senate Judiciary committee.

“Revitalized Enforcement”

Kohl applauded Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. for his efforts. Kohl said that, “as our economy rebounds, the Antitrust Division’s revitalized enforcement has fostered a competitive marketplace that encourages innovation and economic development while ensuring consumers have access to high quality goods at the best prices.”

In prepared testimony, the attorney general touted merger enforcement efforts as well as cartel enforcement at the Justice Department Antitrust Division.

“The Department has acted against six merger transactions already in Fiscal Year 2010, reaching settlements to protect competition in the vast majority, including the combination of Ticketmaster and Live Nation, and is currently litigating against Dean Foods, the nation’s largest dairy processor,” Attorney General Holder said. He also noted that the nearly a quarter of a billion in criminal fines were obtained against Antitrust Division defendants so far in the current fiscal year.

While the Justice Department’s role in fighting terrorism was the focus of much of the hearing, antitrust issues were discussed. Before turning to non-antitrust issues, Senator Chuck Grassley (R, Iowa) thanked Attorney General Holder for the Justice Department’s efforts to put on joint antitrust hearings with the Department of Agriculture on the topic of competition in the agriculture marketplace.

The first hearing in the series was held in Iowa on March 12. Attorney General Holder and Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack were in attendance.

Comcast/NBC Universal Merger

Senator Al Franken (D, Minn.) expressed his concerns with the proposed merger of Comcast and NBC Universal, now under review by the Department of Justice.

In light of his experience in the entertainment industry, Franken offered his assistance to the Justice Department as it reviews the transaction. The attorney general said that the Justice Department would be glad to work with him and listen to his concerns.

Senator Franken has expressed concern with the enforceability of potential commitments offered by the parties to resolve federal antitrust concerns. He said that he wanted to make sure that merger conditions have “enough teeth” and “long enough life.”

Attorney General Holder said that he was not at liberty to talk about Comcast/NBC deal specifically because of the ongoing investigation. He did say, however, that the Justice Department has enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance with conditions imposed on merging parties.

Links to a webcast of the Judiciary Committee’s April 14 hearing, as well as Attorney General Holder’s prepared testimony and Senator Kohl’s remarks, are available here.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010





Trade Regulation Tidbits

This posting was written by Darius Sturmer, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Notes on recent state enforcement actions:

 American International Group (AIG) has agreed to pay $9 million to settle a lawsuit by the State of Ohio alleging violations of the state’s antitrust laws. AIG, the world’s largest insurance company, was alleged to have conspired with insurance broker Marsh & McLennan and other insurers to eliminate competition in the commercial casualty insurance industry. The state’s complaint asserted that the insurers and Marsh agreed to provide customers with fictitious quotes creating the false impression that competitive bidding had produced the best possible price, during a period extending from 2001to 2004. As a result of the settlement, more than $3 million will be distributed to the 26 public entities, including universities, schools, cities, and counties. Approximately $4 million will be put aside in a fund that will be distributed by the court once the antitrust case has been completely resolved. In an April 7 announcement, Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray noted that while it was “a good settlement for Ohio," the litigation had not concluded. The state is pursuing claims against Marsh & McLennan, ACE American Insurance Co., The Chubb Corporation, and Hartford Financial Services Group.

 The New York Attorney General's Office has filed litigation in state court challenging mattress maker Tempur-Pedic International, Inc.'s alleged restrictions on dealer discounting. The state contends that Tempur-Pedic prohibited its retailers from discounting its mattresses. Mattress retailers acknowledge that adhering and agreeing to the manufacturer's suggested retail prices is required to remain as a Tempur-Pedic retailer, according to the allegations. The state is seeking restitution to consumers and disgorgement under New York state law.

 Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal announced on April 1 that the La Quinta Inn hotel chain has formally agreed to cease "call-arounds"—a potentially anticompetitive practice in which competing hotels exchange current room rate and occupancy information. The state attorney general's antitrust investigation into the hotel industry, which remains ongoing, has found that the call-around practice is prevalent in the hospitality industry and raises serious antitrust concerns because the information can be manipulated to raise or stabilize rates charged for hotel rooms. According to Blumenthal, the investigation has revealed that certain competitors of La Quinta have used call-around information to raise their prices on a regular basis, violating the Connecticut Antitrust Act. La Quinta's agreement to end call-arounds covers all La Quinta Inn and La Quinta Inn & Suites hotels nationally. The prohibition does not prevent hotels from reviewing commercially available reports and information, communicating with any other hotel or motel on behalf of a specific guest seeking to relocate, or communicating with any other hotel/motel to accommodate guests in the event of a state of emergency, disaster or similar situation. Further details appears here on the Connecticut Attorney General's website.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010





Buyers of Municipal Derivatives Adequately Allege Conspiracy to Fix Prices, Allocate Customers

This posting was written by Jeffrey May, Editor of CCH Trade Regulation Reporter.

Municipalities and other purchasers of municipal derivatives adequately alleged a conspiracy to allocate customers and fix prices for municipal derivatives, the federal district court in New York City has ruled. A motion to dismiss a second consolidated class action complaint (SCAC) was denied.

The defending financial services companies sought dismissal on the ground that the SCAC failed “to allege any facts showing a single conspiracy among all the defendants, or among any subset of defendants regarding the entire municipal derivatives industry.” The SCAC provided more specific allegations regarding certain defendants' involvement in the conspiracy than was alleged in the original consolidated class action complaint.

The plaintiffs relied on information obtained “in the context of a settlement process” from a defendant that had entered into the antitrust corporate leniency program administered by the Department of Justice Antitrust Division, as well as information provided by a confidential witness who is cooperating with the Justice Department in its antitrust investigation.

The SCAC was viewed in light of developments in state and federal investigations into the municipal derivatives industry. Although pending government investigations might not, standing alone, satisfy an antitrust plaintiff’s pleading burden, government investigations could be used to bolster the plausibility of Sherman Act, Sec. 1 claims, the court explained.

Statute of Limitations

The original complaint was ultimately dismissed because the claims were based upon events that occurred outside of the applicable statute of limitations period. The SCAC, however, sufficiently alleged fraudulent concealment so as to toll the statute of limitations.

Because allegations of bid rigging and price fixing were self-concealing, the plaintiffs were not required to show that the defendants took independent affirmative steps to conceal their conduct. Rather, the named plaintiffs needed to plead only ignorance of the violation and due diligence, both with the particularity required by Rule 9(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

They alleged that they were put on notice of their antitrust claims only after one of the defendants participated in the Department of Justice Leniency Program, approximately one year before the complaint was filed. With respect to due diligence, the named plaintiffs pled with particularity the inquiries that were made, to whom they were made, regarding what, and with what response.

Preclusion of Claims

The claims were not precluded by “an extensive set of federal regulations governing the operation of the market for tax-exempt municipal debt,” the court decided. The defendants unsuccessfully argued that private antitrust enforcement was precluded because awarding damages to the named plaintiffs would conflict with Internal Revenue Service and Treasury Department regulations governing tax-exempt debt, including the reinvestment of municipal bond proceeds.

Implied preclusion analysis turned on four considerations:

(1) whether the underlying market activity lies squarely within the heartland of the IRS regulations;

(2) whether the IRS had the authority to regulate the activities in question, namely a conspiratorial agreement to rig bids and fix prices;

(3) whether the IRS has regularly exercised its legal authority to regulate the alleged price fixing and bid rigging practices; and

(4) whether application of the antitrust laws to the challenged conduct would conflict with application of the IRS regulations.

Only the first prong weighed in favor of implied preclusion. The investment of tax-exempt municipal bond proceeds—the underlying market activity—fell squarely within the heartland of IRS regulation. The other three considerations weighed against implied preclusion, in the court's view.

The text of the decision in Hinds County, Mississippi, v. Wachovia Bank, appears at 2010-1 Trade Cases ¶76,954.